Create your own ultimate cheese tray with three cheeses of your own selection. Use the menu below to choose your favorites from across the US and around the globe. We'll head to our cheese cave, cut and wrap your cheese to order, and pack them in our yellow Deli gift bag with a loaf of our Farm bread. Each piece weighs in at at least half a pound, for just over a pound and a half of cheese total.
Cheese not your jam? We have plenty of other
customizable gifts, too. Or if you'd like to create a custom gift box with other ingredients we're happy to help. Give us a ring at 888.636.8162.
Zingerman's Nor'easter Cabot Cheddar
Pasteurized cow's milk cheddar from Cabot in Vermont. Great for snacking. Half pound.
Marieke Gouda
Raw cow's milk gouda from Wisconsin. Rich, dense, sweet and savory. Half pound.
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese
Raw cow's milk cheese from Wisconsin. Fruity, rich, deep, sweet. Half pound.
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar
Traditional pasteurized cow's milk cheddar from Vermont. Complex, tangy, and fruity. Half pound.
Sold Out
Manchester Cheese
Soft, double-cream round of cow's milk cheese from Zingerman's Creamery. Luscious. Half pound.
Piave Vecchio
Pasteurized cow's milk cheese from northern Italy. Sweet, fruity, toasty flavor. Half pound.
Taleggio Cheese
Pasteurized cow's milk cheese from Italy. Soft texture, funky mushroomy flavor. Half pound.
Sold Out
Camembert
Soft round of pasteurized cow's milk cheese from France. Vegetal, complex, funky flavor. Half pound.
Comté Cheese from Fort St. Antoine
Raw cow's milk cheese from France. Rich, brothy, bright, and fruity all at once. Half pound.
English Farmhouse Cheddar
Traditional raw cow's milk cheddar from Britain. Bold, grassy, intense cheddar tang. Half pound.
Challerhocker Cheese
Raw cow's milk cheese from Switzerland. Creamy, intense, nutty, fruity. Half pound.
Antique Gruyère
Raw cow's milk cheese from Switzerland. Smooth, fruity, slightly swissy flavors. Half pound.
Emmentaler Swiss Cheese
Raw cow's milk cheese from Switzerland. Classic Swiss flavor, amplified. Half pound.
Brabander Goat Gouda
Pasteurized goat's milk gouda from the Netherlands. Incredibly sweet and creamy. Half pound.
Brebis d'Ossau
Raw sheep's milk cheese from France. Creamy texture, mellow, fresh, fruity flavor. Half pound.
L'Amuse Pril Young Gouda Cheese
Pasteurized cow's milk gouda from the Netherlands. Creamy, milky sweet caramel flavor. Half pound.
Artisanal Manchego
Pasteurized sheep's milk cheese from Spain. Smooth, nutty, fragrant. Half pound.
Sold Out
Essex Street Manchego
Raw sheep's milk cheese from Spain. Sweet and savory, nutty, bright, complex. Half pound.
Sold Out
L'amuse Signature Aged Gouda
Pasteurized cow's milk gouda from the Netherlands. Extra aged, huge butterscotch flavor. Half pound.
Sold Out
Valserena Parmigiano Reggiano
The classic. Raw cow's milk cheese from Italy, aged at least two years for huge flavor. Half pound.
Bayley Hazen Blue Cheese
Raw cow's milk blue cheese from Vermont. Fudgy texture, rich, smooth flavor. Half pound.
Sold Out
Colston Bassett Stilton
Pasteurized cow's milk blue cheese from Britain. Slightly sweet, smooth blue flavor. Half pound.